Precautions of Expenditure Method of National Income

Expenditure Method Precautions: Complete Guide for Students
📊

Expenditure Method Precautions

Master the precautions of expenditure method for Calculating National Income

Why These Precautions Matter

When calculating national income using the expenditure method, we need to be very careful about what we include and what we don't. Think of it like making a recipe - if you add the wrong ingredients or add some ingredients twice, then your final dish will not taste good! Let's explore these important precautions with easy examples.

Identify Expenditure
Apply Precautions
Calculate National Income
1

Final Goods vs Intermediate Goods

When calculating national income, we should only consider final goods and services - those that have already reached the end consumer. Intermediate goods (used to make other goods) should be excluded to avoid double counting.

Exclude: Intermediate Goods

Raw materials, components, and goods and services used in production process

Include: Final Goods

Finished products purchased by end consumers

Real-Life Examples
Example 1 - Bread Making: When calculating national income, we count the ₹30 spent by a family buying bread from a bakery (final good). We do NOT count the ₹10 the bakery spent on flour, ₹5 on yeast, and ₹3 on salt (intermediate goods). If we counted both, we'd be counting the flour twice!
Example 2 - Car Manufacturing: We include the ₹8,00,000 a customer pays for a new car (final good). We exclude the ₹50,000 the car company paid for steel, ₹30,000 for tires, and ₹20,000 for electronics (intermediate goods) because their value is already included in the final car price.
Example 3 - Restaurant Meal: Count the ₹500 a customer pays for dinner at a restaurant (final service). Don't count the ₹100 the restaurant paid for vegetables, ₹50 for spices, and ₹30 for cooking oil (intermediate goods) as these are already reflected in the meal price.
2

Second-Hand Goods

Second-hand goods were already counted when they were first produced and sold. Including them again, would mean double counting! However, any commission or service fees paid, during the resale should be included as these represent new services.

Exclude: Purchase Price of Used Goods

The actual price paid for second-hand items

Include: Commission & Service Fees

Fees paid to dealers, brokers, or platforms for facilitating the sale

Real-Life Examples
Example 1 - Used Car Purchase: Rahul buys a 5-year-old car for ₹3,00,000 from a dealer. We DON'T count this ₹3,00,000 ( as already counted in the year when the car was first produced and sold). But We DO count the ₹15,000 commission Rahul paid to the dealer for facilitating the sale as this is a new service provided in this year.
Example 2 - Online Marketplace: Priya sells her old iPhone for ₹25,000 on an online platform. We exclude the ₹25,000 transaction value but include the ₹1,250 platform fee (5% commission) as it's a new digital service provided this year.
Example 3 - Real Estate: A family buys a 10-year-old house for ₹50,00,000. We don't count the purchase price in national income. But we do include the ₹1,00,000 commission paid to real estate agent and ₹25,000 in legal fees as these are new services provided during the current year.
3

Financial Assets

Buying shares, bonds, or debentures doesn't produce new goods or services - it's just transferring ownership. These are "paper claims" that don't add real value to the economy. But brokerage fees and commissions paid for these transactions are new services and included in national income.

Exclude: Purchase of Financial Assets

Money spent buying shares, bonds, debentures

Include: Brokerage & Commission

Fees paid to brokers and financial service providers

Real-Life Examples
Example 1 - Stock Investment: Amit invests ₹1,00,000 in Reliance shares and pays ₹500 brokerage. We exclude the ₹1,00,000 investment (as it is just ownership transfer) but we will include ₹500 brokerage fee, as it's a financial service provided by the broker this year.
Example 2 - Government Bonds: A bank buys ₹10,00,000 worth of government bonds and pays ₹2,000 in transaction fees. The bond purchase is not included in national income, but the ₹2,000 fee paid is a new service produced this year.
Example 3 - Mutual Fund Investment: Sneha invests ₹50,000 in a mutual fund with a 2% entry fee (₹1,000). We don't count the ₹50,000 investment amount in national income, but we do include the ₹1,000 entry fee, as it represents fund management services provided during the current year.
4

Imputed Values

Sometimes people produce things for themselves or use their own property. Even though no sale is made, but these activities have economic value and should be included. We estimate these "imputed values" based on market prices.

Include: All Imputed Values
  • Own account production: Companies using their products internally
  • Self-consumption: Farmers eating their own crops
  • Owner-occupied housing: Estimated rent for houses people own and live in
Real-Life Examples
Example 1 - Company Fleet: Maruti Suzuki manufactures cars worth ₹20,00,000 for its own employee transportation, instead of buying from another company. Even though no sale occurred, we include this ₹20,00,000 as it represents production of new goods in the current year.
Example 2 - Farmer's Consumption: Farmer Ramesh grows wheat worth ₹50,000 and his family consumes ₹15,000 worth of it instead of selling in the market. We include ₹15,000 as imputed consumption, because it is production during the current year.
Example 3 - Owner-Occupied House: Dr. Sharma lives in her own house worth ₹1 crore. Similar houses in the same locality will rent for ₹50,000/month. We include ₹6,00,000 annual imputed rent in national income calculations, because Dr. Sharma is providing herself a housing service worth that amount.
5

Transfer Payments

Transfer payments are money given without receiving any goods or services in return. These don't represent new production or economic activity - they're just moving money from one person to another. Including them would overstate the economy's actual output.

Exclude: All Transfer Payments
  • Scholarships : Money given to students
  • Donations: For Charitable purpose
  • Gifts: On Social Occasions
  • Unemployment Allowance: Government Support payments to unemployed
Real-Life Examples
Example 1 - Educational Scholarship: The government gives Meera a ₹1,00,000 scholarship for her engineering studies. This is not included in national income because no new goods or services were produced - it's just transferring government money to a student to support her education.
Example 2 - Wedding Gift: Mr Rajesh gives ₹2,00,000 as a wedding gift to his nephew. This is excluded from national income calculation because it's just moving money between family members. There is no new production of goods or services.
Example 3 - Charity Donation: A businessman donates ₹10,00,000 to an orphanage during a natural disaster. While this is socially valuable, it is not included in national income because no new goods or services were produced.

Quick Reference Guide

Remember these key points when applying the expenditure method

🎯 Final Goods Only

Count finished products, not raw materials or components

🔄 No Double Counting

Exclude second-hand goods but include commission and Brokerage

📄 Paper vs Real

Exclude financial assets but include transaction fees and brokerage

💭 Estimate Hidden Value

Include imputed values for self-production and consumption

🎁 No Free Money

Exclude transfer payments - they don't create new economic value

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *